First published on the Steem blockchain by @remlaps on March 01, 2025. View the original post.
TL;DR: Fighting a respiratory virus by culling chickens is a bad idea: It doesn't work; high food prices hit vulnerable people the hardest; and it creates counterproductive evolutionary pressures.
Introduction
In recent weeks, the American media has begun to focus on the currently elevated price of eggs. For example (via Brave Search):
- Eggcellent alternative: High egg prices causing people to rent and raise their own chickens
- Trump’s got a bird flu plan. So when will eggs stop costing so much?
- Egg prices expected to rise more than 40 percent in 2025
- Egg Shortage: Trump Administration Announces $1 Billion Plan To Lower Egg Prices
- Is Bird Flu the Only Reason Egg Prices Are Soaring?
It seems that one of the primary reasons that egg prices are high, and expected to remain that way, is because hen farmers are being required to cull their flocks as a result of bird flu outbreaks. This is described by The Independent as follows,
Skyrocketing egg prices are largely the result of a widespread bird flu outbreak that forced a mass culling of egg-laying birds. With fewer birds, there are fewer eggs, and with scarcity comes increased cost.
It seems to me that this mandatory culling is a really bad idea. Why? Three reasons:
- It doesn't work.
- The resultant high prices hit marginalized communities the hardest
- The evolutionary result of this policy will be bird flu variants that spread more easily and are harder to detect.
Let's look at all three arguments.





























